I think some, not all, but some college fans take the game far too seriously. When you are at the point of hoping the player should die, then you are probably taking it too far. Have you ever physically retaliated against someone? If so, should you die? I dont condone the eye poking, but think realistically here.
Charlie, had this occurred in a Wisconsin-Whitewater vs. Wisconsin-La Crosse matchup, would this be a very big issue to you? Would you even care to see what other message boards had to say about the incident? Think sensibly now. I think its unwarranted and stupid to claim someone should die because of an incident on the field. Its not like he raped, killed, and dismembered the body. Then to follow up and claim anyone who says "thats what happens in the pile" can die along with him? Guess what. Getting poked in the eye does happen. The majority of the time it isnt intentional, but it happens. And thats what I think Ryan was getting at, and I was agreeing with. Shields serve more of a purpose than looking cool and keeping grass and sun out of your eyes. It also keeps fingers out, because that does happen.